If I Started an Investment Fund

by mikekarnj on November 22, 2009

Someday in the distant future, I would love to be an investor.  I’m a huge supporter of nurturing entrepreneurship (tech+social) in New York City, and would love to see more startups launching in that space. Let’s say I started a small $50M fund, I would split my investments over the following: 1) investing in companies; 2) investments to support the NYC startup movement; 3) donating to innovative non-profits; and 4) investing into people.

The companies listed below are in no particular order, and I selected them based on innovation/idea, management team, opportunity, and “excitement.”  Or in other words, whether I get excited by the idea or not.  The reason I have “excitement” listed as one of the filters for companies is because I would love to spend time with each of the companies and lend my ideas, creativity, connections, etc to make their ideas and companies more successful.

New York Based-Companies

  1. Kickstarter is a new way to fund creative ideas.  Kickstarter is a funding platform for artists, designers, filmmakers, musicians, journalists, inventors, explorers…
  2. Behance is a company that organizes the creative world to make their ideas happen.
  3. Harvest allows small businesses to track time, log expenses, invoice clients, keep track of account receivables and revenue.
  4. Foursquare gives you and your friends new ways of exploring your city.
  5. 20×200 (Jen Bekman Projects) is a website for art collectors. The site releases at least two new limited-edition prints a week: one photo and one work on paper.
  6. Hunch is a decision-making site that gets smarter the more it’s used.
  7. By/Association is a private service for personal introductions to remarkable people.  (Disclaimer: I’m Co-Founder)
  8. Eat.ly allows you to track your meals and discover new social food via images.
  9. TBD is a free email newsletter that delivers one world-shaking idea and one collective action to improve our future.  (Disclaimer: I’m Co-Founder)
  10. Hello Health is an innovative new primary care practice platform that helps doctors communicate, document, and transact with their patients in person and online.
  11. Quirky is a social product development company.
  12. Boxee is the first social media center, an open-source software platform for entertainment across computers or traditional living room devices.
  13. Carbonmade helps you build and manage an online portfolio website.
  14. Frogtek is an early-stage social venture that will bring the IT productivity boom to micro-entrepreneurs in the developing world.
  15. SHE “is developing a franchise model to manufacture and distribute eco-friendly sanitary pads using local materials, such as banana fibers. The aim is to sell pads for 30 percent less than existing brands, while creating a profit so that the model can be self-replicating.”

Outside of NYC Companies

  1. Vittana is an early-stage startup bringing student loans to the developing world through the power of person-to-person microfinance.
  2. Fitbit accurately tracks your calories burned, steps taken, distance traveled and sleep quality.
  3. 23andMe provides genetic testing for over 100 traits and diseases as well as DNA ancestry.
  4. NAKEDpizza’s mission is to make an unhealthy and popular fast food healthy, raising consciousness about nutrition, health and the food supply, as well as the social impact and obligations of modern business.
  5. Full Tilt Poker is the fastest growing online poker room.

Investments to Support NYC Startup Movement

  1. I would invest into incubator programs like the Y-Combinator, Unreasonable Institute or Techstars version based in NYC.
  2. I would invest into world-class events like The Feast (Disclaimer: I’m Co-Founder) or TEDxNewYork (if there is one).
  3. I would invest into co-working spaces such as New Work City and Green Spaces.

Investments in Innovative NYC Non-Profit Organizations

  1. charity: water is a non-profit organization bringing clean and safe drinking water to people in developing nations.
  2. Echoing Green invests in and supports outstanding emerging social entrepreneurs to launch new organizations that deliver bold, high-impact solutions.

Investments into People (Superstars)

Rafe Furst wrote an article on “investing into superstars” where investors would buy a percentage of someone’s expected lifetime earnings.  I followed up with a whole article on why the idea is so revolutionary (and light years ahead of its time).

Imagine you are in your early twenties, out of college several years and your best friend, who recently came into an inheritance of $300K cash told you they could think of no better way to invest the money than to invest it in you.  Not the company you started, not as a loan, but invest it in YOU, as if you were a startup.  In return your friend said all they wanted was 3% of your gross income for the rest of your life.  Do you think you would take it?

Now what if your friend said that they didn’t care what you did with the money or how much you made each year.  If you wanted to sit on a beach in Nicaragua learning to surf, go work in the Peace Corps, stay at home and do your art projects, whatever you want it would be fine, just as long as you made sure to always pay the 3% of whatever you make (as little as that may be).

And finally, what if your friend said you could buy out of your obligation at any point for $6 million in cash.  Then would you take the deal?

I would do the same for this investment fund.

So, all in all, these are the companies, ideas, and people that would make up the portfolio of my investment fund.  Obviously, the fund would make these investments to turn a profit and get a nice return.  But, I also believe in supporting the greater good — supporting the startup movement already happening in New York City.  Who would you add to the list?

  • http://spencerfry.com Spencer Fry

    I’d also add the following to neat NYC startups: Bug Labs, Etsy and Tumblr. There are plenty of others not listed, but I think they’re especially need recognition of startups you haven’t already listed.

  • http://mikekarnj.com/blog Michael

    Yep, I thought about adding those to the list. If we’re listing out great NYC startups, here are a couple mor that I think are awesome…

    - Vimeo
    - Drop.io
    - Squarespace

  • http://www.scott-technology.com Ken Moreano

    I think that this is well intended and building community / culture around innovation and entrepreneurship is important however I believe we fail to recognize a few issues:
    1. Who invests in the “small $50M fund”, when the funds states that of the 4 categories for capital deployment, only one is in companies?
    2. The slog that it is to be an entrepreneur. Specifically high growth entrepreneur. These are the ones that receive the investment and are expected to turn that into anywhere from a 6X to 20X return.
    3. While the slog is taking place, there is much in the way of assisting the companies that the fund needs to provide (assuming that the fund has the expertise and ability). If not there, more than likely the portfolio will struggle.
    4. If the strategy is to leverage each of the 4 categories to assist the fund’s portfolio, it may be helpful but the points above are likely issues.

  • http://mikekarnj.com/blog Michael

    Ken,

    Great points.

    1) $50M is an arbitrary number. It could be $10M. It could be $100M. I looked at the fund as if we had no Limited Partner’s and I had somehow struck it rich to invest my own money : )

    2) Very true but how often does that happen? Theoretically, that makes sense. Realistically, VC returns have dipped below zero. You have a better chance of throwing darts to pick companies or stocks that would outperform most VC funds.

    http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/02/02/venture-capital-returns-dip-below-zero/

    3) Agree as well. I think this is an essential key ingredient to ensure success of startups and entrepreneurs.

    4) My goal would be a mix between profits and social benefit. I think the two go hand-in-hand. The return from building a community/culture around entrepreneurship is tremendous outweighing any financial return from a single company.

  • http://www.scott-technology.com Ken Moreano

    1. Understood. The issue becomes clear that less than $10M is likely insufficient as the fund will likely need to provide follow on funding for any specific portfolio deal. Also, industry focus will likely determine who much capital will be needed for each deal.
    2. I do not disagree on the landscape of VC funds and their performance however this is the expectation. We can debate as to the why and the various factors but these comments are not for debate, more for conversation.
    4. If a fund is successful in your local community, there will likely be inherent value and community benefit. There are examples of a strong financial return for a single deal in a community creating a much greater social impact. Just imagine if Google had been established in your community. The wealth creation, M&A activity, attraction of talent and spin offs that have occurred as a result all impact the community as well as the X prize they started.

  • Pets Adoption >> Adopt a pet to …

    ..]one another relavant source of information on this issueis ,www.mikekarnj.com,..]

  • http://www.taylordavidson.com/writing/2009/11/30/investment-thesis/ An Investment Thesis | Taylor Davidson

    [...] Michael Karnjanaprakorn, If I Started an Investment Fund [...]

  • http://www.alldaybuffet.org/2009/12/01/why-social-innovators-will-lead-the-next-generation-of-business/ Why social innovators will lead the next generation of business

    [...] partner recently wrote a great post about the start ups he would invest in, but I figured I would blow out his thoughts into where I [...]

  • http://whatconsumesme.com/2009/shared-posts/why-social-innovators-will-lead-the-next-generation-of-business/ Why social innovators will lead the next generation of business / what consumes me, bud caddell

    [...] partner recently wrote a great post about the start ups he would invest in, but I figured I would blow out his thoughts into where I [...]

  • http://www.scott-technology.com/ Ken Moreano

    I think that this is well intended and building community / culture around innovation and entrepreneurship is important however I believe we fail to recognize a few issues:
    1. Who invests in the “small $50M fund”, when the funds states that of the 4 categories for capital deployment, only one is in companies?
    2. The slog that it is to be an entrepreneur. Specifically high growth entrepreneur. These are the ones that receive the investment and are expected to turn that into anywhere from a 6X to 20X return.
    3. While the slog is taking place, there is much in the way of assisting the companies that the fund needs to provide (assuming that the fund has the expertise and ability). If not there, more than likely the portfolio will struggle.
    4. If the strategy is to leverage each of the 4 categories to assist the fund's portfolio, it may be helpful but the points above are likely issues.

  • http://www.boots-stores.us uggs outlet

    Dior homme shoes
    I've been looking for a similar to this post. Not only extensively but also detailly. We can learn a lot from the post. I recommend to you , you can come communication in here. Let us grow up together.On the other hand ,I know some websites content is very well.you can go and see.Such as XXXXX

  • http://www.geniusshoppers.com/ Warcraft Accessories

    Hello!I am following your blog for many weeks now. I have to say that it is very informative. It is already added in my bookmarks and i will make sure that i will follow it frequently. Thanks for the nice posts .